QPR in crisis: why the players are as much to blame as Mark Hughes

Chris King on why Mark Hughes is not the only reason behind the Rs’ abject start to the season, and a run of 12 games without a league victory.

Queens Park Rangers lie five points clear of safety at the foot of the Premier League table after a damaging 3-1 defeat to Southampton. The performance produced by the vast majority of those sent out to represent the club on the pitch was nothing short of atrocious, but sadly it was not an aberration.

Fury | Queens Park Rangers manager Mark Hughes feels the heat during his side’s abject 3-1 loss to Southampton. (Image | The Telegraph)

Despite not having picked up a win for 11 matches, supporters vocally backed their side early on before the Saints took control of the game and imposed themselves upon the hosts. Only three players – captain Ryan Nelsen, Adel Taarabt and substitute Jamie Mackie – are exempt from the following assessment.

Rs manager Mark Hughes is facing the sack for the club’s wretched start to the season. This is only right and correct, for he has consistently offered lame excuses for defeats, over-focused on injuries and misfortune and avoided the fact that not once this season have Rangers played well: not once.

Whatever mistakes the Welshman has made throughout his tenure, and there have been many, what fans are so quick to forget is that a manager only picks the team. While his charges are on the pitch there is very little he can actually do to influence what takes place, let alone control it.

Regrettably, it seems that QPR are in the throes of a mutiny which is causing players boasting successful careers at the highest level of European football, such as Djibril Cissé, Esteban Granero, Júlio César, Jose Bosingwa and Ji-sung Park, to turn in performances that would embarrass 14-year-olds having a kick about in the local park.

The ineptitude on display against Southampton was astounding, while the inertia and unwillingness to obey even the simplest rules of the game, such as not allowing dangerous wingers to cut inside and shoot at will, is a stain on the professionalism of the individuals at fault.

Hughes deserves to be sacked, if only for promising that Rangers would not be in the same position as they finished in last season, 17th, while he was in charge. His words are likely to ring true – the Rs look to on course to remain in the relegation zone from now until May.

Battling | Only a handful of players, including Adel Taarabt, could escape without criticism following the result on Saturday. (Image | Daily Mirror)

Yet the fact remains that the players provided for Hughes by owner Tony Fernandes have proven largely to be mercenaries. Individuals such as Shaun Wright-Phillips, Cissé, César, Park, Granero and Bosingwa appear to have taken one look at the club and sensed that they could extract whopping salaries for doing very little.

For if QPR do go down at the end of the season, which is fast becoming a certainty, it will cost millions to release all the past-their-best brigade, many of whom signed up to long-term contracts knowing full well that the board and its enthusiastic owner had not a clue what they were letting themselves in for.

A banner at the match called for Harry Redknapp to “come and save us”, but while the former Tottenham Hotspur boss is an excellent man-manager, he does not come cheap, and nor will he be expecting to skimp on reinforcements in the January transfer window.

This crisis extends well beyond who is sitting in the dugout, and it is almost impossible to pinpoint where it started. Since the first minute of the opening game against Swansea City back in August, the players have looked disinterested, week after week.

Row | Striker Djibril Cisse’s decision to argue with an understandably frustrated QPR fan on Twitter will go unpunished by the club, but he could become a hate figure for the home crowd. (Image | The Telegraph)

We have not been unlucky, we have been woeful. Defeats on the road have become about as certain as day and night, and a record of five goals at home in six matches is completely unacceptable. Against the Royals, Cissé did nothing but score. For a striker this is almost permissible: the only problem is, he does this every single time, and has only found the net once in the league.

For players to show no passion, no commitment, no drive, no determination, no ability, no common sense, no concern, no impetus and absolutely no appreciation of just what a crisis QPR are facing is completely and utterly unforgivable. This was the case on Saturday, when every single player bar Taarabt, Mackie, Nelsen and to a small extent Diakité, sold Hughes down the river.

Whenever the gaffer is relieved of his duties, and a successor appointed, this group of overpaid, under-committed charlatans must start performing. They have already gone down in history as being responsible for one of the worst starts Rangers have ever made to a season. Now they owe us, the long-suffering supporters – who pay upwards of £600 to watch them fail – with a significant improvement, and fast.

Have your say | Tweet the author | @chriskking

Originally published on Football Speak on Monday November 19 2012.


2 thoughts on “QPR in crisis: why the players are as much to blame as Mark Hughes

  1. You are of course right about the players’ responsibilities, but on the other hand…

    Sparky’s team do indeed lack much spark, but then again he’s got to be culpable because he at least has some influence on the signings, and while the underperforming Park seemed like an eminently sensible signing over the summer, previous signings like Cisse and Zamora have never been known as consistent goalscorers.

    He doesn’t seem to know his best team either.

    Bosingwa, the Da Silva kid on loan from united, even Taarabt who’s been in and out of form since QPR’s promotion are likewise unreliable.

    To be fair, the summer saw lots of players come and go, so it’ll take time to gel a new team, but I’m increasingly convinced that QPR can’t take the risk on Sparkles to be the one to do it. It’s a shame because I think your club is fantastic, but it’s stick or twist – the last thing you want is to lose the manager just before or after the transfer window.

    I hope things turn around for you though.

    I’m a Leeds fan for what it’s worth and I know only too well the bitter feeling of knowing the club made the wrong decision about the manager and that the absolute best you can hope for is that you avoid a relegation dopgfight. More than once – Ken Bates kept Dennis Wise for far longer than he should’ve done, for example.

    We’ve had Ken Bates for far longer than is fair. I know the rest of the football league likes the idea of us paying penance for being dirty Leeds but come on… That’s another story though.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s